A veteran military journalist recalls many instances during their years reporting on the defense establishment when the actual narrative diverged significantly from the official account.
After the capture of Baghdad in 2003, the then defense secretary was openly overjoyed, insisting it signaled the triumph of the military campaign. Yet, via unofficial discussions with military officers, the reporter soon learned a more complex reality: more American troops were needed to secure logistical routes being targeted by supporters of the former government.
“Was I, as a journalist, seeking out information?” they stated. “Naturally. That is the essence of journalism. Finding out the actual events behind the scenes and not accepting completely what any government says.
This journalist is among many defense correspondents confronting the revocation of their official access after declining to accept a controversial directive from the defense chief. The requirement would force reporters to sign an agreement asserting they will solely report information “officially approved” by the military establishment.
Transformation from Watchdogs to State Functionaries
Signing such an agreement would essentially convert journalists “from independent observers into government mouthpieces”, as noted by a former chairman of a major press association and ex- editor of a global news agency.
This journalist is in good company. News organizations including leading newspapers, wire services, and digital outlets – including some with conservative audiences – are refusing the demand.
Predictably, a network widely regarded as a state-friendly broadcaster has consented to sign.
Television Outlets Support the Protest
In a major move, the major TV networks – including those considered supportive of the government – issued a joint statement expressing their rejection.
“The directive is without precedent and endangers core press freedoms,” they announced. “We will persist to cover the US military as we has done for many decades, maintaining the values of a free and independent press.”
This near-unanimous stance is justified – and it is encouraging to witness such unity. This kind of journalistic cohesion is formidable – and the public could use more of it, particularly when the press are frequently under siege.
Journalism vs. Stenography
No matter how much the Pentagon leadership might desire it, journalism is not stenography, and the government-sanctioned story is frequently only a beginning for more thorough reporting that uncovers the facts.
The policy has been characterized as a “assault on facts” that obviously threatens the purpose of constitutional protections and undermines the public’s right to know what their government is doing.
The defense chief's response to this widespread defiance was characterized by a juvenile display of digital icons on social media, dismissing organizations that refused to comply.
Escalation of Media Controls
This latest action constitutes an escalation in controls. Not only does the Department of Defense rarely hold media availabilities these days, but previously it also banned reporters from most of the facility without an minder. This deviation from past practice hindered the capacity of correspondents to gather nuanced information through routine contacts.
Under the new policy, journalists could be designated a security risk simply for asking defense personnel for sensitive information.
Persistence of The Press
It is certain that reporters and their news outlets will persist to report on the operations of the Pentagon, educating the public about their leaders' actions.
Credentials is not paramount. In fact, the professional pursuit for proximity to powerful people and institutions – and the desire to protect that privilege – may hinder accurate reporting.
As a former journalist noted, the press can continue doing their jobs through means other than transmitting officially approved information to the public.
“Reporting of the armed forces can be pursued through leaks, freedom of information petitions, and additional cooperative means harnessing the legal system’s protections,” the journalist stated. And they can continue to do so, they added, “until this benighted regime reaches its conclusion.”